Speculation about their status arose when Butler, widely recognized for his role in Elvis, was noticeably absent from Kaia's family vacation in Cabo San Lucas over the New Year. The trip, which included her parents, Cindy Crawford and Rande Gerber, as well as her brother Presley Gerber and his girlfriend, Isabella Jones, typically would have included Austin.
The couple, who began dating in 2021, were once a prominent fixture in the public eye. From red-carpet appearances to personal milestones, such as Austin assisting Kaia with her move to a new home in mid-2023, they often appeared inseparable. At the time, their closeness even sparked engagement rumors, though these were quickly dismissed by sources close to them.
Despite their shared history, signs of a split became apparent in recent months as they were seen together less frequently. However, their separation has been described as mutual, with no lingering animosity.