Amelia and Andrew first captured hearts with their undeniable chemistry during a Golden Globes red-carpet interview in 2023. Their October chicken shop date only fueled fan excitement, but Amelia seemingly placed the 41-year-old actor in the friend zone. Now, her conversation with Elmo suggests she may have second thoughts. At the seven-minute mark, Amelia opens up, saying, “I met someone recently… I really like them. I feel like I was in my head and maybe friend-zoned them before we could even begin.”
Elmo, ever supportive, responded, “Oh, Elmo’s sorry to hear that,” while Amelia remained optimistic, adding, “It was a great date though. We’ve got real chemistry… I don’t know, we’ll see how it goes.” Elmo concluded the exchange with his trademark wisdom: “There’s always room for love.”
Fans quickly took to social media, speculating Amelia’s comments were about Andrew. “Imagine Elmo is the reason Andrew Garfield and Amelia end up together,” one user wrote. Another joked, “If they’re using Elmo to hard launch, so help me god.”
Viewers praised the episode as one of Amelia’s best, with comments like, “This is a masterclass on acting with a puppet,” and, “Elmo matches Amelia’s vibe perfectly.” The playful yet emotional video has reignited hopes for an Amelia-Andrew romance, with fans eagerly waiting to see if love truly prevails.