At the time, Garner had just landed a small part on Law & Order alongside Benjamin Bratt. Before their scenes, Bratt suggested they meet for coffee to get acquainted. Despite never having tried coffee before, a young Garner eagerly agreed.
During their meeting, Bratt ordered a double latte with an extra shot, which amounted to three shots of espresso. Garner, wanting to keep up, ordered the same drink and added a generous amount of sugar. When Bratt ordered a second round, Garner didn’t hesitate to join in.
However, the heavy caffeine intake left Garner feeling jittery and anxious. The effects were so overwhelming that she had to cancel an audition scheduled later that day. Despite that shaky first experience, Garner has since become a coffee enthusiast. She now enjoys almond milk cappuccinos, flat whites, or cortados, as reported by PEOPLE.